A federal court docket sided with the well being teams in 2019, compelling the FDA to begin imposing its authorization course of for e-cigarettes firms. The FDA gave e-cigarette makers a deadline of 2020 to use for authorization, or be pressured off cabinets. (That deadline was later pushed again, due to Covid.) Juul had already been on sale for 4 years, and by then made up 75 p.c of the e-cigarette market. However its future started to look cloudy.
Juul now had to pivot. The corporate, as Jamie Ducharme writes in her 2019 guide Large Vape, modeled itself after a typical San Francisco startup, the place folks would “skateboard backwards and forwards throughout the workplace’s concrete flooring and shoot one another with foam Nerf darts.” Many early workers, like founders Monsees and Bowen, had design and advertising backgrounds. Juul now needed to adapt to regulatory scrutiny, producing intensive experiences about its product’s elements, substances, and well being dangers to win FDA authorization.
The corporate began hiring folks to deal with authorities relations and handle public affairs. It additionally crippled its personal product lineup, pulling its hottest flavors—corresponding to mango and fruit medley—from the cabinets to go away solely menthol, mint, and tobacco pods. The corporate’s announcement of the information quoted then CEO Okay. C. Crosthwaite pledging to “reset the vapor class by incomes the belief of society and dealing cooperatively with regulators, policymakers, and stakeholders.”
Many US lawmakers had been unimpressed. A spate of mysterious lung accidents linked to different vaping firms additional tarnished the brand new business’s repute. In 2019, San Francisco banned all vaping merchandise that had not been reviewed by the FDA—stopping Juul from promoting its merchandise in its hometown. By the top of the yr, Congress had accredited laws to boost the nationwide age for e-cigarette gross sales from 18 to 21.
None of that has threatened Juul fairly as a lot because the FDA, which started to take huge swings on the vaping market. In 2020 it ordered a halt on gross sales of all vaping merchandise with candy and fruity flavors, as Juul had appeared to anticipate, and in 2021 it denied advertising approval to greater than 55,000 flavored e-cigarette merchandise.
Lastly, in June of this yr, the FDA got here for Juul, denying its personal advertising utility and ordering its merchandise off the market. Whereas the official reasoning mentioned the corporate supplied insufficient toxicology knowledge, FDA commissioner Robert M. Califf famous in an announcement that Juul might have “performed a disproportionate function within the rise in youth vaping.”
Even when Juul survives, its second as a disruptive market chief might have handed. Jeong, the Cornell graduate, says his friends stopped utilizing Juuls when the corporate discontinued its in style flavors. Individuals favored mint, which remained on the cabinets, however nobody wished to puff on a tobacco-flavored Juul.
Somewhat than dropping their vaping behavior, his pals moved on to different manufacturers that emerged to select up Juul’s declining market share. One in all them, Fume, nonetheless sells flavors like pineapple, which Jeong describes as “consuming a piña colada,” because of a brand new regulatory loophole. The FDA’s ban applies to flavored vape cartridges, like Juul’s pods, however not disposable e-cigarettes, which come precharged and prefilled. By 2020 the disposable Puff Bar, with flavors like Banana Ice and Blue Razz, had changed Juul as the preferred vaping system amongst teenagers.