Although Ehrlich opposed poverty, he by no means pushed for a redistribution of wealth. To him, individuals had been finest described in numbers, like butterflies and different bugs. His treatments for overpopulation had been draconian: steep taxes on diapers, mass sterilization, and the addition of sterility brokers to meals exported to overseas populations. In 1969, Stewart Model, certainly one of Ehrlich’s Stanford protégés, instructed an interviewer at an overpopulation protest, “We’d wish to see individuals have fewer kids—and higher ones.”
In 1971, Garrett Hardin, who had a PhD from Stanford in microbiology, went additional. In a New York Occasions opinion piece, Hardin argued flatly for stripping ladies of “the best to breed.” The Southern Poverty Legislation Heart now calls Hardin’s writings “frank of their racism and quasi-fascist ethnonationalism.”
MUSK GRABBED the inhabitants panic mic round 2020. He sounded contrarian, even papal. Although he had elsewhere expressed indifference to caring for infants—and has been disowned by certainly one of his 10 kids—he was quoted in The New York Occasions as saying “infants are supercool.” Moreover, by siring an enormous brood, he instructed the Journal viewers, “I’m making an attempt to set a very good instance.”
Musk additionally introduced, on the Lex Fridman Podcast, that “intercourse with out procreation … is sort of a foolish motion.” Some Catholic traditionalists pounced, claiming Musk had gone full Humanae Vitae. In the meantime, the fashionable NoFap set, who chorus from masturbation in an effort to channel their mojo into nobler issues, additionally claimed Musk as a brother.
Others on the best are equally panicking about delivery charges. J. D. Vance, the Ohio-based enterprise capitalist, mewled to Tucker Carlson final yr that “childless cat girls” run the US. To advertise pregnancies in such girls, Vance—his logic shaky—proposed an “outright ban” on pornography. “If we would like a wholesome ruling class on this nation … we must always assist extra individuals who even have children,” he stated.
Inhabitants issues rattle Carlson too. For years he’s been preoccupied with unnamed ghouls who’re disappearing white individuals to interchange them with “new individuals, extra obedient voters from the Third World.” The culprits are white ladies of his personal social class for not being fruitful sufficient. In July, Carlson instructed the journalist Ben Smith that he’s “not mad at Black individuals” as a result of he reserves that vitriol for a “38-year-old feminine white lawyer with a barren private life.” “I hate you!” he shouted merrily.
Vance and Carlson are deep within the far-right tank, however Musk might by no means benefit from the full conservative embrace. His thought of cool infants, in spite of everything, extends past white infants. In an deal with to Republican fats cats in August, Musk faulted the occasion for its stand in opposition to immigrants and urged the GOP to indicate extra compassion.
This wasn’t as candy because it appeared. Immigrants, to Musk, are only a greater labor pool; he welcomes anybody who will do manufacturing grunt work for lengthy hours and low pay. If delivery charges shot up, however the brand new individuals, as a substitute of working for him, subsisted on authorities packages, Musk—the infamous tax-avoider—may change his tune.
Each inhabitants ideology finally skews sinister. Opponents of underpopulation, identical to opponents of overpopulation, problem decrees of their thunderous means merely to hide a monstrous program of eugenics. Ehrlich needed fewer poor individuals; Vance and Carlson need extra white ruling-class individuals; Musk needs extra professional bono laborers. None of them need precise warm-blooded individuals, the oddballs we be taught from, collaborate with, even love. I can’t emphasize this sufficient. Caring about butterflies or bots doesn’t imply caring about people. Mark my phrases.
In case you purchase one thing utilizing hyperlinks in our tales, we might earn a fee. This helps assist our journalism. Study extra.
This text seems within the November 2022 problem. Subscribe now.